Although one of the episodes I enjoyed least, Fear Her’s redeeming quality is the fact that Rose Tyler, ultimately, emerges as a worthy companion. Although faced with a challenge fit for the Doctor, Rose has learned enough from her adventures.
Rose Tyler finally becomes capable of solving a mystery all by herself. The fact that she found the Isolus and singlehandedly convinced Chloe’s mother to help, showed character growth. Rose Tyler started out as a scared teenager, nineteen years old. But now, she is a twenty and more fully alive than she ever thought possible.
Another interesting element in Fear Her was the revelation that the Doctor had been a father. In some other galaxy, in a different time, and before the Time War, the Doctor had somehow managed to become a father. He had a family, a wife, and children – or just one child, we can’t be sure. The revelation took my completely by surprise because I must reconcile the fact that even Time Lords must have desired some kind of normal, quiet life. The audiences are jolted back to the objective reality wherein the Doctor is the last of his kind, never capable of leading a life like he had back on Gallifrey.
Speaking of Gallifrey, more recent episodes have actually shown some images of that far-flung place. Thank God for photoshop:
And, because this particular episode was particularly efficient in directing our thoughts towards the Time Lords, here’s a glimpse of what they used to look like:
Chloe Webber’s situation is directly juxtaposed with the Doctor’s experiences, his own loneliness, because he too must deal with a more permanent form of separation and loss. The episode effectively reminded its audience that the Doctor, no matter how many people or aliens or sub humans he saves, will never be able to save his own planet, or his own people. Despite being capable of many, countless, noble deeds, despite surviving, he can do nothing to save his family.
Even Rose seems taken aback. We have previously known the Doctor in a limited capacity but this new bit of information leads our curiosity to different avenues. We wonder about the Time Lord culture, if there was such a thing as a monogamous, permanent relationship. Who were the authorities that permitted or sanctioned such unions? We also wonder, again, almost painfully, regarding the Doctor’s former life. Was he a soldier? He said that he fought on the frontline.
I thought that Fear Her wasn’t particularly gripping. Its plot was a little too convoluted and convenient to be believable. I wasn’t drawn to the child, I wasn’t particularly impressed with the historical event that they visited, and the monster – in this case, the Isolus – wasn’t frightening at all. I felt that the domestic drama between Chloe, her mother, and her deceased father, wasn’t too strong or very well wrought to be effective. I felt that the concept was not well thought-out given the success of previous episodes.